The College Football Playoff Selection Committee dropped its third rankings of the 2025 season on Tuesday, November 18, 2025—and the biggest surprise wasn’t at the top. It was Oklahoma Sooners, climbing three spots to No. 8 after pulling off a stunning 31-28 road win over then-No. 4 Alabama Crimson Tide. The upset, played on November 15, 2025, in Tuscaloosa, didn’t just shake the rankings—it reshaped the entire playoff landscape. Now, with an 8-2 record, the Sooners are one win away from hosting a playoff game in mid-December. And yes, it’s that simple: win out, and they’re in.
How Oklahoma Climbed the Ladder
Oklahoma’s rise wasn’t just about beating Alabama. It was about consistency under pressure. The Sooners are now 3-0 on the road in the SEC—a feat no team had accomplished since the conference expanded its football footprint. They’ve also racked up four wins over teams that were ranked at the time of the game, including Auburn (when they were No. 17) and now Alabama. "It’s not just the win," said Parker Thune on OU Insider’s November 19 analysis. "It’s that they did it in the SEC, on the road, against a program that’s historically owned this kind of game. The committee noticed. They’re not just watching wins—they’re watching context."
That context matters. If Oklahoma defeats Missouri this weekend, they’ll become the first team since 2015 to notch five top-25 wins in a single season. That’s not just a stat—it’s a legacy marker. And with Notre Dame and Alabama tied at No. 9 and No. 10, respectively, the Sooners are now the clear leader among one-loss teams outside the Power Five.
The Oregon Controversy
But here’s the twist: Oregon, at 9-1, sits at No. 7—just one spot ahead of Oklahoma. And that’s where the backlash began. Mussatto of The Oklahoman didn’t hold back in his November 19 column: "Oregon over Oklahoma in the playoff rankings is nonsense. Oregon has one win over a ranked team—Arizona State—and lost to a 6-4 Washington team. Oklahoma has beaten four ranked opponents, including the No. 4 team in the country. The committee is rewarding schedule strength with one hand and ignoring it with the other."
It’s a fair point. Oregon’s only loss came to Washington, and they haven’t played a single team ranked in the top 10 since September. Oklahoma’s schedule? Brutal. They’ve played six games against teams that were ranked when they faced them. The committee says it values "overall strength of schedule," but the math doesn’t match the perception.
What’s at Stake
The College Football Playoff system—headquartered in Irving, Texas—uses a 12-team bracket starting this season. The top four get a first-round bye. Teams ranked 5 through 12 play in the CFP First Round, with higher seeds hosting. That means Oklahoma, at No. 8, needs to win their final two games to guarantee a home game on December 20 or 21.
But here’s the catch: even if they win out, they might still have to play Ohio State in the Big Ten Championship Game if Ohio State wins out and claims the conference title. That’s a potential trap. "If they beat USC," noted Brandon Drumm on OU Insider, "and Oregon loses to Oregon State, then Oklahoma could sneak in as a higher seed. But if Oregon wins, and Ohio State wins, and Oklahoma wins... we’re looking at a three-way tiebreaker scenario. And the committee doesn’t like ties. They’ll pick the team with the better head-to-head. And Oklahoma doesn’t have one against Oregon."
That’s the silent threat. No direct competition. No tiebreaker advantage. Just wins, wins, and more wins.
The Road Ahead
Oklahoma’s next test is Missouri on Saturday, November 23. A win there gives them "insulation," as Thune put it—a buffer against any potential slip-up against West Virginia in the Big 12 Championship. But even if they lose, they’re still in contention. The committee’s final rankings come after all regular-season games conclude on December 7. That’s 18 days from now. Eighteen days for upsets, injuries, and drama to unfold.
Meanwhile, the top four remain locked in: Ohio State (10-0), Indiana (11-0), Texas A&M (10-0), and Georgia (9-1). The battle for the final two spots? That’s where the chaos lives. Oklahoma, Oregon, Texas Tech, Ole Miss, and even Utah (8-2) are all within one game of each other in the pecking order.
Why This Matters
This isn’t just about Oklahoma. It’s about the credibility of the new 12-team system. Fans are watching. Media are dissecting. And the committee? They’re under more scrutiny than ever. If they rank a 9-1 team with one top-25 win ahead of an 8-2 team with four—including a top-5 upset—then the system looks arbitrary. But if they reward Oklahoma’s grit, their schedule, and their road dominance? Then the playoff becomes a true test of merit, not just record.
The final rankings drop on December 8. The championship game is set for January 20, 2026, at Mercedes-Benz Stadium in Atlanta. But for now, the story belongs to Norman, Oklahoma—where a team that was written off in October is now one win away from history.
Frequently Asked Questions
How did Oklahoma jump from No. 11 to No. 8 in just one week?
Oklahoma jumped three spots after defeating then-No. 4 Alabama in a dramatic road upset on November 15, 2025. The selection committee rewarded the Sooners for their strength of schedule, which includes four wins over teams ranked at the time of the game, and their perfect 3-0 record in SEC road games. The previous week’s ranking (No. 11) didn’t account for Alabama’s fall from contention after the loss, which created a ripple effect across the top 10.
Why is Oregon ranked higher than Oklahoma despite having fewer ranked wins?
Oregon (9-1) is ranked No. 7 because of their higher overall win total and a stronger non-conference schedule, including a win over then-No. 15 Arizona State. But critics argue the committee is undervaluing Oklahoma’s tougher slate, which includes victories over Alabama, Auburn, and Texas Tech—all ranked at game time. The lack of a head-to-head matchup between the two makes direct comparison impossible, leaving the committee to rely on subjective "quality of wins," which has sparked debate among analysts.
What does Oklahoma need to do to host a playoff game?
Oklahoma needs to win its final two regular-season games—against Missouri on November 23 and West Virginia on December 7—to guarantee a top-8 seed and a home game in the CFP First Round. Even if they lose one, they could still host if Oregon or Texas Tech lose their conference title games. But a loss to Missouri would make their path far more precarious, especially if Oregon wins out.
Is this the first time Oklahoma has had five top-25 wins in a season?
No, but it’s the first time since 2015. That year, Oklahoma went 11-2 with wins over Alabama, Texas, TCU, West Virginia, and Oklahoma State—all ranked at game time. If they beat Missouri and West Virginia this season, they’ll match that mark. No team since has achieved five top-25 wins in a single season, making this a historic benchmark for the current roster.
How does the 12-team playoff format work this year?
The top four teams get a first-round bye. Teams ranked 5–12 play in the CFP First Round, with higher seeds hosting. Conference champions are prioritized, but the committee can select up to seven non-champions. The final rankings, released December 8, determine all matchups. The championship game is January 20, 2026, at Mercedes-Benz Stadium in Atlanta. Oklahoma’s path to the title requires winning two games, then potentially navigating a semifinal against Ohio State or Indiana.
Who makes up the College Football Playoff Selection Committee?
The committee has 13 members, including former coaches like Frank Beamer, former athletic directors like Tom Holmoe, and longtime media members such as Gary Danielson. Their identities are public, but their individual votes are not. They meet weekly to rank teams based on win-loss record, strength of schedule, head-to-head results, and conference championships. No single member has veto power, but consensus drives the final rankings.
Write a comment